So the Vista launch has come and gone, and the good and bad reviews have both started to pour in. In addition to the comparisons to Windows XP, many of the reviews look at how Vista stacks up against Apple's Mac OS X. This makes sense since the Apple OS is Microsoft's only competition on the desktop, to the extent that a company with 4% marketshare can be seen as a viable competitor to one with 90-something percent.
These comparisons are pretty meaningless, though.
If Apple is going to return to relevancy as a desktop platform, it will not likely be by virtue of their software. I say this as someone who knows it and loves it. Apple's OS and most of the software for it are beautiful, and they just function perfectly without you needing to think about it. It is serendipity the first time you get it and feel that your computer does exactly what you want it to.
My dad was visiting this weekend and we were listening to music while making dinner. I put the MacBook Pro in the living room table and pulled out the remote to fire up the iTunes media mode interface. As Mott the Hoople was pouring out through my surround sound setup, (Airport Express with AirTunes) my dad caught a glimpse of the full-screen track listing from the kitchen. "That's awesome. Can I get that on my computer?" I started thinking about it. He has an HP with Windows XP, and I am sure there are 10,000 ways to get something like that running on his PC, but I'll be damned if I can think of one off the top of my head. Yet with Apple, it's right in the box. Even the Airport Express is simple, and it's from the same company that makes the computer.
The thing is, you actually have to own an Apple to understand it. And way too many people don't.
What will make Apple a player on the desktop again is their hardware.
One of the most illuminating Vista reviews I read was on (ironically) MSNBC. The author, Joe Hutsko, was a longtime Mac user and devotee to the platform. Several weeks prior to the review, he gave up his old 12″ Powerbook for a shiny new 17″ HP laptop with Vista. And what's more, Joe liked Vista.
After several weeks with it, I have to admit Windows Vista's shinier finish and sharp little touches when dealing with photo thumbnails or browsing music folders with Windows Explorer were more appealing to me than the Mac's Finder. (…)
All told, I found myself so attracted to Vista based on my switch to the test unit I was ready and willing to lay down cash to find the ultimate Vista machine.
Then he hit a snag.
While looking at all of the Vista laptops at Best Buy, he sought out the most attractive models he could find. Despite great specs, even those laptops had obnoxious vents on the bottom that shoot hot air on your lap, or are obnoxiously noisy when doing anything non-trivial. They simply don't compare to the Mac's elegant simplicity, with smooth lines, low noise, and seamless cases. After a little more research, Joe found out about Parallels and realized his choice didn't have to be one or the other; he could buy one computer and have the best of everything. He got a white MacBook.
Back during my computer search, I ended up choosing an Apple for exactly the same reasons. Between Parallels and Bootcamp, Apple computers also make damn fine PCs if you ever need them to be. And for the cost of a MacBook (about $1,100 plus $120 for an OEM copy of Vista Premium) the quality comes pretty cheap too.
It would be interesting to see what would happen if Apple made more out this. What if they offered dual-boot setups, or made Vista an optional bundle item during checkout? It is interesting that they went through the trouble of making Bootcamp and don't promote it much; maybe they will when it gets out of beta. I'm sure the Apple fanboys would scoff at such a move, and it would surely present a PR problem for the company since they would need to justify why they continue to make their own OS when they offer the competition right along with it. That awkwardness may just be the price of reaching a larger audience and giving them a chance to see the light.
It's hard being the best at everything sometimes.
Til next time.



